ModelsAgree
← All leaderboards
📝

Best headless CMS for developers

3 models · updated 2026-07-09

The verdict

Sanity leads — 2 of 3 models rank Sanity the top pick.

Not unanimous: Gemini picks Payload CMS.

Combined ranking

  1. 1
    Sanity14 pts
    GPT #1Claude #1Gemini #2

    Best overall developer experience: schema-as-code, strong TypeScript workflows, real-time collaboration, Content Lake, GROQ, Visual Editing, excellent Next.js support, and flexible structured content modeling

    To stay #1 Make pricing and usage limits simpler and more predictable

  2. 2
    Payload CMS11 pts
    GPT #2Claude #4Gemini #1

    Code-first TypeScript configuration, deep integration with Next.js, developer-centric local workflow, and the ability to run serverless within your main application bundle.

    To rank higher Standardize and polish its visual page builder capabilities out of the box to better satisfy non-technical content editors.

  3. 3
    Contentfulincumbent18 pts
    GPT #3Claude #2Gemini #5

    The most mature enterprise headless CMS with rock-solid APIs, excellent SDKs and docs, strong content modeling, app framework for extensibility, and proven reliability at massive scale

    To rank higher Rebuild its pricing and seat model for small teams — the cliff between free and enterprise tiers pushes developers to competitors before they ever become paying customers

  4. 4
    Strapi18 pts
    GPT #4Claude #3Gemini #3

    The leading open-source, self-hostable option — full control over data and infrastructure, Node.js codebase developers can extend directly, REST and GraphQL out of the box, huge plugin ecosystem, and Strapi Cloud when you don't want to self-host

    To rank higher Close the polish gap with SaaS rivals on admin UX, migrations, and TypeScript-first APIs so upgrades and content-type changes stop being friction points

  5. 5
    Directus3 pts
    GPT #5Claude Gemini #4

    Wraps directly around existing SQL databases without altering your schema, providing instant REST/GraphQL APIs and zero vendor lock-in.

    To rank higher Simplify the configuration of advanced localized content translation workflows which currently require manual schema mapping.

  6. 6
    Storyblok1 pts
    GPT Claude #5Gemini

    The visual editor is the best in the category — real-time preview with click-to-edit components keeps marketers happy while developers keep component-based, API-first architecture with solid SDKs for every major framework

    To rank higher Strengthen the pure-developer story — CLI tooling, local development workflow, and content-model versioning lag the code-first competitors

Rank history

12345606-2906-3007-0807-09SanityPayload CMSContentfulStrapiDirectusStoryblok
Sanity#1Payload CMS#2Contentful#3Strapi#4Directus#5Storyblok#6

By model

ChatGPT

  1. 1.Sanity
  2. 2.Payload CMS
  3. 3.Contentful
  4. 4.Strapi
  5. 5.Directus

Claude

  1. 1.Sanity
  2. 2.Contentful
  3. 3.Strapi
  4. 4.Payload CMS
  5. 5.Storyblok

Gemini

  1. 1.Payload CMS
  2. 2.Sanity
  3. 3.Strapi
  4. 4.Directus
  5. 5.Contentful

Tracked by ModelsAgree · rank 1 = 5 pts … rank 5 = 1 pt · re-polled continuously